BIL vs SHV
SPDR Bloomberg 1-3 Month T-Bill ETF vs iShares Short Treasury Bond ETF
Bottom line: Both are ultra-safe cash alternatives; BIL holds 1-3 month T-bills with minimal rate sensitivity, while SHV reaches slightly further out for marginally more yield.
At a Glance
| BIL | SHV | |
|---|---|---|
| Issuer | State Street | BlackRock |
| Index Tracked | ICE Short Treasury Bond Index | ICE Short US Treasury Securities Index |
| Expense Ratio | 0.1354% | 0.1354% |
| Data Start Date | 2007-06-01 | 2007-02-01 |
Price History
Cash-like Treasury exposure
BIL holds Treasury bills maturing in 1 to 3 months. SHV holds short Treasuries generally maturing within about a year. Both are backed by the US government and function as parking spots for cash, offering yield with negligible credit risk.
The difference is a small step out on the maturity curve, which slightly changes yield and price stability.
Yield versus stability
SHV's marginally longer maturity usually means a touch more yield than BIL, but also a bit more price sensitivity if rates move. BIL is about as stable as an ETF gets — its price barely fluctuates — making it a near-perfect cash equivalent.
When the yield curve is inverted, as it has been recently, the very shortest bills in BIL can actually yield as much as or more than slightly longer ones in SHV, narrowing any advantage.
Which to use for cash
For an emergency fund or dry powder you might deploy at any moment, BIL's rock-steady price is ideal. For cash you can leave alone a little longer and want to squeeze marginally more yield from, SHV is reasonable.
Both serve the 'cash' sleeve in strategies like the Permanent Portfolio. The choice between them is minor compared to simply holding a T-bill fund rather than idle cash.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is BIL or SHV better for holding cash?
BIL holds 1-3 month T-bills and has the most stable price, making it ideal for cash you may need anytime. SHV reaches slightly further out for marginally more yield with a bit more price movement. Both are very safe.
Are BIL and SHV safe?
Yes. Both hold short-term US Treasury securities backed by the federal government, so credit risk is minimal. Their prices are very stable, which is why they are used as cash alternatives.
Hypothetical historical performance based on backtested data. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This site is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Full disclaimer